TOEFL vs IELTS for US Universities and Healthcare Professionals (2026)
TOEFL or IELTS for foreign nurses, doctors, and pharmacists applying to US nursing schools or VisaScreen? Full comparison of score requirements, test format, and which is easier.
Key Takeaways
- Both IELTS Academic and TOEFL iBT are accepted by CGFNS for VisaScreen - the Speaking minimums are equivalent (IELTS 7.0 ≈ TOEFL 26)
- IELTS Academic is the safer choice for VisaScreen because all US state nursing boards accept it; a minority of state boards prefer IELTS over TOEFL
- Most US nursing schools accept both tests - IELTS 6.5-7.0 or TOEFL iBT 79-100 depending on programme level
- TOEFL is entirely computer-based with integrated tasks; IELTS has a face-to-face speaking interview - choose based on your strengths
- TOEFL iBT overall 83 ≈ IELTS overall 6.5 for VisaScreen; TOEFL Speaking 26 = IELTS Speaking 7.0
- Neither test is universally easier - performance depends on your learning background and test format preferences
Should foreign nurses and healthcare professionals take TOEFL or IELTS for the USA?
For US nursing VisaScreen (CGFNS), both IELTS Academic and TOEFL iBT are accepted. The speaking minimums are equivalent: IELTS Speaking 7.0 and TOEFL Speaking 26. IELTS Academic is recommended because it is accepted by all US state nursing boards, whereas a minority of state boards specify IELTS over TOEFL. For US nursing school admissions, both tests are generally accepted. Neither test is universally easier - choose based on test format preference: TOEFL is computer-based only, IELTS uses face-to-face speaking.
- Both tests accepted for VisaScreen; IELTS Academic is safer (accepted by all state boards)
- Speaking equivalent: IELTS 7.0 ≈ TOEFL 26 - the hurdle is the same
- TOEFL: entirely computer-based, integrated tasks; IELTS: paper/computer + face-to-face speaking
- Most US nursing schools accept both; check the specific programme's requirements
AI-ready answer · mockde.com
For guidance purposes only. University admissions requirements and state nursing board policies change. Always confirm current requirements directly with CGFNS, your target state nursing board, and your chosen university before booking a test.
TOEFL vs IELTS for US Healthcare: Which Should You Take?
Quick Answer
For VisaScreen (nursing licensure visa): take IELTS Academic - it is accepted by every US state nursing board. TOEFL is also accepted by CGFNS but a minority of state boards prefer IELTS, so choosing IELTS avoids any state-specific risk.
For US nursing school admissions: both tests are accepted at virtually all programmes - choose the one that suits your learning style and testing strengths.
Choose IELTS Academic if…
- You prefer a face-to-face speaking interview over recording spoken responses to a computer
- You want the broadest state-board acceptance (all US states accept IELTS)
- You are comfortable with pen-and-paper reading and writing under timed conditions
- You have already taken IELTS before and know the format
Choose TOEFL iBT if…
- You are more comfortable typing than writing by hand and processing tasks on screen
- You find recording spoken responses less stressful than a live interview
- You have confirmed that your specific state nursing board accepts TOEFL
- You already have TOEFL preparation materials and are familiar with its format
IELTS Academic vs TOEFL iBT: Full Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | IELTS Academic | TOEFL iBT |
|---|---|---|
| Test format | Paper-based Reading & Writing; computer or paper Listening; face-to-face Speaking | Entirely computer-based, including integrated Reading+Listening tasks |
| Speaking assessment | Face-to-face interview with a trained examiner (3 parts, ~14 min) | Computer-recorded responses to 4 tasks (no human interviewer) |
| Writing | Task 1 (data description) + Task 2 (argumentative essay) - independent tasks | Integrated writing (summarise a lecture after reading a passage) + opinion essay |
| Listening | 4 sections: monologues and dialogues in everyday/academic settings | Lectures and conversations from university settings only |
| Score scale | 0–9 band (each component and overall) | 0–120 total (4 sections, each 0–30) |
| VisaScreen minimumKey | 6.5 overall, 7.0 Speaking | 83 total, 26 Speaking |
| Score validity | 2 years | 2 years |
| Accepted for US nursing VisaScreen | Yes (all states) | Yes (most states - confirm with your state board) |
| Accepted for California BRN | Yes (7.0 overall, 7.0 Speaking required) | Yes (confirm specific score with BRN) |
| Accepted for US university nursing programmes | Yes (virtually all) | Yes (virtually all) |
| Test duration | ~2 hours 45 minutes | ~3 hours |
| Availability | Daily computer-based; paper-based ~48 times/year | Available year-round at test centres and home |
Source: CGFNS VisaScreen guidance; ETS TOEFL iBT information; Cambridge Assessment English (IELTS). May 2026.
TOEFL vs IELTS for VisaScreen: What You Must Know Before Choosing
CGFNS officially accepts IELTS Academic, TOEFL iBT, and OET for the VisaScreen Certificate. In theory, you have a choice. In practice, there are three reasons why IELTS Academic remains the default recommendation for foreign nurses and healthcare workers targeting the USA.
State nursing board acceptance is not uniform for TOEFL
A small number of US state nursing boards specify IELTS Academic (or OET) and do not explicitly list TOEFL iBT in their approved tests. If you submit a TOEFL result to one of these boards, your application may be returned. IELTS Academic is the one test that no US state nursing board rejects for this purpose.
California BRN - TOEFL acceptance must be confirmed directly
The California Board of Registered Nursing has historically been cautious about updating its approved test list. If California is your target state, contact the BRN directly to confirm current TOEFL iBT acceptance before investing in test preparation.
The Speaking equivalent is the same - the hurdle does not disappear with TOEFL
A common misconception is that TOEFL Speaking is 'easier' than IELTS Speaking. The Speaking minimums for VisaScreen are equivalent (IELTS 7.0 ≈ TOEFL 26). The nature of the task is different - TOEFL uses recorded responses to computer prompts, while IELTS uses a live interview - but the proficiency level required to meet the minimum is the same.
Practical recommendation: Unless you have a specific, confirmed reason to prefer TOEFL (format preference, existing preparation, confirmed state-board acceptance), take IELTS Academic. It eliminates state-board risk and is the most universally recognised test for US nursing purposes.
IELTS and TOEFL Requirements at US Nursing Schools
If you are applying directly to US nursing programmes (BSN, MSN, or DNP), the admission English requirements are set by the university, not by CGFNS. Most US nursing schools accept both IELTS Academic and TOEFL iBT. The table below shows indicative requirements at major nursing programmes - always verify with each institution.
| School / Programme | IELTS Academic Min. | TOEFL iBT Min. | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Johns Hopkins University (MSN) | 7.0 | 100 iBT | Graduate nursing programmes |
| University of Pennsylvania (BSN/MSN) | 6.5-7.0 | 100 iBT | Check programme-specific requirements |
| University of Michigan (BSN) | 6.5 | 84 iBT | Undergraduate entry |
| Duke University (MSN) | 7.0 | 100 iBT | Graduate nursing entry |
| New York University (MSN) | 7.0 | 100 iBT | Rory Meyers College of Nursing |
| University of Florida (BSN) | 6.5 | 80 iBT | Undergraduate entry |
| University of Texas (MSN) | 6.5 | 79 iBT | Graduate entry threshold |
| VisaScreen (CGFNS) - all US nursing statesFederal Requirement | 6.5 overall, 7.0 Speaking | 83 total, 26 Speaking | Federal requirement for occupational visa |
Indicative requirements based on published university admissions information, May 2026. Always confirm directly with the university's admissions office.
Strategy if applying to both university and VisaScreen simultaneously
If your goal is a US nursing school programme and eventual VisaScreen for licensure, target the higher of the two requirements from the start. VisaScreen's hard 7.0 Speaking minimum often exceeds university minimums for individual components - aiming for 7.0 Speaking satisfies both. A single test sitting with strong scores across all components saves time and test fees.
The Speaking Hurdle: IELTS 7.0 vs TOEFL 26 - Are They Really Equivalent?
The most common question from foreign nurses choosing between IELTS and TOEFL is: "Is TOEFL Speaking easier to score?" The short answer is that the proficiency level required is the same - but the test experience is different, and that difference matters for preparation.
IELTS Speaking (3 Parts)
- Part 1: 4–5 min. Personal questions about your life, work, hobbies
- Part 2: 2 min. Speak on a cue card topic - 1 min to prepare
- Part 3: 4–5 min. Abstract discussion linked to Part 2 theme
- Delivered face-to-face with a trained human examiner. Your performance is scored live and later verified.
TOEFL iBT Speaking (4 Tasks)
- Task 1: Independent - your opinion on a topic (15 sec prep, 45 sec speak)
- Tasks 2–4: Integrated - summarise what you read + heard
- All responses recorded and scored by AI + human raters. No live interaction. Prep time is shorter per task.
TOEFL Speaking Tasks 2–4 require listening + reading simultaneously
If you find it hard to take notes while listening, TOEFL integrated speaking tasks add cognitive load that IELTS does not have. IELTS Part 2 is purely from your own knowledge and memory.
IELTS Part 3 abstract discussion is 4–5 minutes of extended conversation
If you freeze or lose fluency in extended speaking, IELTS Part 3 exposes this more than TOEFL's 45-second spoken responses. Some candidates find shorter TOEFL responses easier to manage under pressure.
Human vs computer assessment of speaking
IELTS is assessed by a trained human examiner who can probe and follow up. TOEFL speaking is machine-scored with human verification. Some candidates prefer the predictability of recorded responses; others prefer the natural conversation of an IELTS interview.
Bottom line: The speaking hurdle exists in both tests at an equivalent level. Choose the format in which you can most naturally produce extended, fluent, accurate speech. If you have not yet taken either test, taking a free diagnostic practice test for each format will help you identify which suits you better before committing to preparation.
Is IELTS or TOEFL Easier to Score 7.0 (or the VisaScreen Equivalent)?
Both tests require comparable levels of English proficiency for their respective VisaScreen minimums. The research on test difficulty comparison is clear: there is no statistically significant difference in pass rates between the two tests at equivalent proficiency levels. What determines which test is "easier" for you individually is your specific strengths and preparation background.
| Candidate Profile | Better Choice | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Strong handwriting, prefers written exam conditions | IELTS Academic | Paper-based Reading and Writing; pen-and-paper environment familiar from many education systems |
| Comfortable typist, prefers structured computer tasks | TOEFL iBT | All sections on-screen; typed writing; familiar for candidates from tech or business backgrounds |
| Anxious in live speaking interviews | TOEFL iBT | Speaking is recorded, not live - no examiner in the room; shorter response times per task |
| Strong in extended monologue and conversation | IELTS Academic | Part 2 (2-min long turn) and Part 3 (extended discussion) reward candidates who speak fluently at length |
| Healthcare professional - wants broadest licensing board acceptance | IELTS Academic | Accepted by 100% of US state nursing boards; eliminates state-specific compliance risk |
For a full IELTS vs TOEFL vs PTE comparison including non-healthcare visa routes (Canada PR, UK visa, Australia), see: IELTS vs TOEFL vs PTE: Which Test Should You Take?
Do not switch tests mid-preparation without good reason. Both IELTS and TOEFL require test-specific preparation strategies. Switching from IELTS to TOEFL (or vice versa) after several weeks of preparation loses that investment. Commit to one test, prepare thoroughly, and retake the same test if the first attempt falls short.
Start with a free IELTS mock test to find your baseline
If you are leaning toward IELTS Academic, take a full timed practice test first to see where you currently stand across all four components - especially Speaking.
Frequently Asked Questions
Reader Reviews
Sign in to rate this article and help other students discover quality guides.
Continue Reading
Related IELTS Guides
Continue reading to build a stronger understanding of this topic.
